Render courtesy of Binyan Studios
3.2.2021: Developer Towers over Community on Appeal
“The Appellate Division has given developers carte blanche to tell the City what a zoning lot looks like” Read full Statement
2.13.2020: Community WINS in Court!
State Supreme Court Justice W. Franc Perry orders that the Department of Buildings revoke the building permit for the tower at 200 Amsterdam Avenue and remove all floors that exceed the zoning limit.
“The directive to partially demolish the building is appropriate given the willingness of the developer to ignore every sign that their project was inappropriately scaled for the neighborhood and based on a radical and wildly inaccurate interpretation of the Zoning Resolution,” said Elizabeth Goldstein, president of the Municipal Art Society, one of two groups that brought the suit.
8.15.2019: CURBED reported that 200 Amsterdam topped out at 52 stories
6.25.2019: Board of Standards & Appeals re-confirmed permits for 200 Amsterdam after court-mandated review. CLICK to read BSA resolution denying appeal.
3.15.2019: State Supreme Court vacates and annuls Board of Standards and Appeals prior ruling as unreasonable and inconsistent with the plain reading of the Zoning Resolution and sends the building permit for 200 Amsterdam Avenue back to the BSA for review.
“200 Amsterdam is an affront to the Zoning Resolution and I am extremely disappointed that the BSA voted to uphold their support for the project. The reluctance to follow the letter of the zoning is astounding, especially when the DOB has acknowledged that the zoning lot is problematic.” - Manhattan Borough President Gale Brewer MORE
READ the full press release by the Municipal Art Society and the Committee for Environmentally Sound Development. Read the court's 200-Amsterdam-Decision_14March2019.
MORE: "Court Deals Blow to Controversial Upper West Side tower"
Background: Gerrymandered Lot Leads to Tallest Building North of 59th Street
200 Amsterdam Avenue is a unique development scenario. Developers SJP Properties and Mitsui Fudosan America planned a 52-story residential development of 668 feet--the equivalent of a 66-story midtown office tower--at the intersection of Amsterdam Avenue and 69th Street. The site was formerly home to the Lincoln Square Synagogue, which relocated further south in a land swap. Availing themselves of the mid-century urban renewal superblock site, the developers ignored zoning and gerrymandered a zoning lot across several tax lots to assemble air rights for additional FAR to create what would be not only the tallest building in the neighborhood, but also the tallest building north of 59th street on the island of Manhattan. Despite a 2017 Zoning Challenge and an appeal to the Board of Standards and Appeals (BSA), construction work continued, although the developers acknowledged that they were choosing to continue building at their own risk as the lawsuit against them made its way to NY State Supreme Court.
Since initially granting this building a permit, the Department of Buildings (DOB) has revised their protocol, issuing a statement that this lot and building height should have not been allowed. (See graphic at left showing the red-outline of the gerrymandered lot, cobbled together from portions of tax lots, that supposedly supports the small blue building lot). The DOB has also prepared a bulletin to clarify zoning intent so that this never happens again.
Yet, the DOB would not revoke the building permit, leaving the community with this monstrously tall building. The Board of Standards and Appeals (BSA) has the authority and oversight mandate to overturn this decision and instruct the DOB to revoke the permit. View a key exchange, led by BSA Commissioner Dara Ottley-Brown, questioning DOB counsel Michael Zoltan (queued up here; click the play button):
…but isn’t that the equivalent of situations where Department of Buildings has a practice- ongoing- does not hold that practice, and then the BSA says that "this is the wrong interpretation and DOB must stop"? It is a similar situation, in that DOB, up until the BSA ruling, is still practicing according to its current interpretation. So why is this different?
...precisely our question as well.
A follow-up hearing of the BSA was scheduled for Tuesday, June 5, 2018. At that hearing, further testimony was given, and the hearing was closed. Lawyers for the Appellant, the Developer, the Department of Buildings and a representative for 170 West End Avenue now were given until June 24th to submit up to 6 additional pages of documentation. The decision hearing of the BSA on this item was scheduled for Tuesday, July 17, 2018 and the vote took place. In a vote of 3 to 1, the BSA sided with the developer and denied the community's appeal.
Previously, Council Member Helen Rosenthal organized 27 of the 51 City Council Members to close a loophole by asking the BSA to refuse to allow gerrymandered lots. Read the full letter to see if your CM signed on!
Read LW! blog posts below for more history on this critical zoning matter.
How the DCP Zoning Text Amendment Stacks UP
Department of City Planning (DCP) hearing on VOIDS Zoning Text Amendment WEDNESDAY, MARCH 13th, beginning at 10am 120 Broadway, Concourse Level LANDMARK WEST! continues our efforts to stop out-scaled development by closing developer loopholes. The Department of City...
Courts side with Developer
Although courts believe that the zoning lot for 200 Amsterdam Avenue has been erroneously assembled, they courts stopped short of revoking the permits but directed the City agencies--the DOB (which is twice on record saying they never should have issued the permits)...
Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal Lowers the Roof on Excess
New York State Assembly Member Linda Rosenthal has introduced state legislation A.5026 aimed at closing the mechanical void loophole. Expanding on an existing zoning text amendment proposed by the New York City Department of City Planning-which is working its way...
Community Boards Consider City Planning text on VOIDS
Mark your Calendars! Key Dates to Curb Inappropriate Development LANDMARK WEST! and our colleagues FRIENDS of the Upper East Side Historic Districts have been pushing back against the spread of Billionaire's Row into our residential districts. Now, reinforced by a...
Manhattan Delegation of City Council speaks out
In a letter dated January 10, the entire Manhattan Delegation of the City Council call upon Marisa Lago, Director of the Department of City Planning and Rick Chandler, the out-going Commissioner of the Department of buildings to prepare "immediate action" toward...
45 West 67th Street
New York, NY 10023